The Cleveland Browns’ quarterback room has been one of the strangest storylines of this NFL preseason, and Monday night’s trade only added another twist. After reports circulated that head coach Kevin Stefanski might carry four quarterbacks into the regular season, the Browns instead opted for clarity, sending Kenny Pickett to the Las Vegas Raiders in exchange for a 2026 fifth-round pick.
It’s a remarkable turn for Pickett, once viewed as a potential franchise quarterback in Pittsburgh. In just over a year, he’s gone from the Steelers’ starter to a Super Bowl backup in Philadelphia to a camp body in Cleveland—and now to the Raiders as an emergency reinforcement.
For Las Vegas, the move was necessary. Aidan O’Connell’s fractured wrist created a glaring hole behind newly acquired starter Geno Smith, who reunited with Pete Carroll after their Seattle years. Carroll wanted insurance with actual NFL starting experience, and Pickett’s 25 starts (15–10 record) give the Raiders at least some peace of mind in case Smith goes down.
For Cleveland, the trade trims a crowded room but leaves open questions behind starter Joe Flacco, who Stefanski already confirmed for Week 1 duty. Pickett’s nagging hamstring injury cost him valuable reps in training camp, and with rookies Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders both showing flashes, there simply wasn’t room to keep everyone.
Now the spotlight shifts back to the youngsters:
-
Sanders, son of Hall of Famer Deion Sanders, generated early buzz with his preseason debut (14-of-23, 138 yards, 2 TDs vs. Carolina) but showed his inexperience in the finale against the Rams, taking five sacks while completing just three passes.
-
Gabriel looked more consistent in limited action, finishing 25-of-37 for 272 yards, one touchdown, and one interception across his two appearances.
Both have shown enough to warrant serious consideration as developmental backups, but neither has separated from the pack. With Tyler “Snoop” Huntley already waived, Stefanski has tough decisions to make before the Tuesday roster deadline.
For now, the Browns are rolling with Flacco at the top, but their backup choice—whether it’s Gabriel’s steadiness or Sanders’ long-term upside—will be closely scrutinized, especially in a season where Deshaun Watson’s health has already forced Cleveland into improvisation mode.
